BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Links to Classic British Flightsim themed images only please.
Please post in jpg or png format and no bigger than 1024 x 768

Moderators: Guru's, The Ministry

Post Reply
User avatar
Mark C
Vulcan
Vulcan
Posts: 444
Joined: 23 Nov 2004, 17:29
Location: NZ & Republic of Colombia
Contact:

BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Post by Mark C »

"In FS" .... I've always liked doing 3 things in particular .... (1) combining real world airline history with virtual aviation .... (2) incorporating as much authenticity "as FS will permit" .... and (3) trying to factor a sense of purpose into each of my own virtual flights too.

The COMET 1, and a rare opportunity to take a break from my HJG activity, recently provided an opportunity for me to do this .... and in doing so also fulfill a particular FS exercise I'd been wanting to undertake for a very long time prior, but, simply hadn't had time to perform .... this being to "fly the historic BOAC route from London/UK to Johannesburg/South Africa" .... following the airlines imperial route of the early 1950's as briefly flown by its COMET 1 aircraft .... and to do so in real time also ;)

The routing I selected .... commenced with a London/Heathrow to Frankfurt/Main sector, then Frankfurt to Rome/Ciampino (old Rome Italy), followed by Rome to Athens/Ellinikon (old Athens Greece), Athens to Cairo/Farouk (Egypt), Cairo to Khartoum (Sudan), Khartoum to Entebbe (Uganda), Entebbe to Nairobi (Kenya), Nairobi to Livingstone (Zambia), and finally Livingstone to Johannesburg/Jan Smuts (South Africa). A total of 8 sectors .... flown at the rate of "1 sector per day" over as many days .... and covering part of western Europe, the Mediterranean, the horn of Africa and eastern side of the African continent (once a region under British political/economic influence) .... all the way down to Johannesburg .... whilst also taking in some of the historic/cultural and geographic wonders of the world along this route and which "ARE" represented in FS by default or available as add-on scenery enhancements.

The Approximate London, Frankfurt, Rome, Athens, Cairo, Khartoum, Entebbe, Nairobi, Livingstone, Johannesburg Route Operated By BOAC DH COMET 1 Aircraft During The Early/Mid 1950's:
Image

Fuel requirements were planned/calculated in accordance with the observed FS fuel burn rates compiled/recompiled into this COMET 1 simulation (since myself and another HJG colleague have have recently performed a wee bit of FDE surgery and which we believe has improved things a little) .... for each flight sector .... and which resulted in loadings well below COMET 1's maximum fuel capacity whilst otherwise simulating a full payload.

For this exercise I also decided to use Tom GIBSON's classic 1950's/1960's era airport scenery (some very nice works of art by Wolfgang GERSCH, Mike STEVENS, and associates which are available from this/Tom's website .... and which I can highly recommend) .... to add a bit of "period ambiance" to each stopover.

To try'n further enhance this feeling of "period ambiance" I also decided to create bit of B&W imagery at each of the 8 stopovers .... of a type that's not intended to resemble good FS imagery, but rather, that which a non-aviation minded tourist embarking on such a long holiday adventure might casually photograph as a personal momento of places visited and scenes observed "whilst killing time at airports" prior to each flight departure .... and which are then additionally supported by the usual obligatory colour imagery showing-off the COMET 1 in action within this add-on FS scenery along each sector of the route flown.

So here we go with this review of my recent BOAC London/Johannesburg circa 1952/1953 routing .... via Frankfurt, Rome, Athens, Cairo, Khartoum, Entebbe, Nairobi, and Livingston .... and flying the classic/pioneering DH 106 COMET 1 jetliner ....

FIRST SECTOR (Day 1) - London/Frankfurt

Pre Departure PAX photo at London:
Image

Departure From London:
Image

This route followed a roughly east-south-easterly track from the London/Midhurst VOR .... across both the English Channel and Belgum .... and on into Germany.

Arrival At Frankfurt/Main:
Image

SECOND SECTOR (Day 2) - Frankfurt/Rome

Pre Departure PAX photo at Frankfurt/Main:
Image

Departure From Frankfurt:
Image

This route followed a south-south-easterly VOR to VOR track from Frankfurt .... trending across western Germany and both Austrian and Swiss borders .... and on into northern Italy.

Arrival At Rome/Ciampino:
Image

THIRD SECTOR (Day 3) - Rome/Athens

Pre Departure PAX photo at Rome:
Image

Departure From Rome:
Image

This route followed a south-south-easterly VOR to VOR track from Rome .... down the west coast of the boot of Italy then trending east-south-easterly out over Ioanian Sea .... toward the Gulf Of Corinth .... and on into Athens.

Arrival At Athens/Ellinikon:
Image

FOURTH SECTOR (Day 4) - Athens/Cairo

Pre Departure PAX photo at Athens/Ellinikon:
Image

Departure From Athens:
Image

This route followed a southerly VOR to VOR track from Athens down to Crete .... then trending south-south-easterly across the Mediterranean Sea and towards Egypt .... to pick up the VOR for Cairo International Airport less than 200 miles DME prior to arrival.

Arrival At Cairo/Farouk:
Image

FIFTH SECTOR (Day 5) - Cairo/Khartoum

Pre Departure PAX photo at Cairo:
Image

Departure From Cairo:
Image

Cairo is where my JEPPESEN E/R charts terminate .... forcing me to then have to resort to a flat world map of the African continent, and use a protractor, ruler, and a pair of dividers in order to determine my route south for the remainder of this trip .... toward Johannesburg .... and to also use "dead reckoning" (distance covered on the basis of airspeed, direction, elapsed time, and estimated drift) after having first previously GOOGLE searched for the necessary/primary VOR and NDB frequencies along each sector so as to aid further relatively accurate navigation south. FS has a built-in GPS .... I know .... but .... using it (to me) is insultingly easy and simply "not challenging enough" (for me) .... essentially robbing one of a the fun (I feel) as well as a sense of accomplishment upon the completion of such an exercise as this .... not to mention also the very real prospect of becoming lost also in the event of inadvertent miscalculations during ones navigation planning, but, which fortunately did not come to pass in my particular case .... as the remainder of this report will indicate :)

The route from Cairo to Khartoum utilized a VOR track almost due South for the first less than 200 miles after departure .... basically following the the Nile Valley into Sudan .... to lock onto the VOR within 200 DME prior to arrival at Khartoum International Airport.

Following departure from Cairo a quick detour was made in order to view the ancient pyramids of Egypt on the Gizeh Plateau at Necrapolis.
Image
The oldest of these 3 pyramids is believed to have been constructed during the 27th century BC. Each is assumed to have taken some 200 years to construct.

Arrival At Khartoum:
Image

SIXTH SECTOR (Day 6) - Khartoum/Entebbe

Pre Departure PAX photo at Khartoum:
Image

Departure From Khartoum:
Image

Again .... this route followed a VOR track continuing almost due south after departure from Khartoum and for the first less than 200 miles DME .... skirting the remainder Nile Valley over southern Sudan .... and on into Uganda .... to pick up the VOR at Entebbe International Airport (on the northern shores of Lake Victoria) within 200 miles DME prior to arrival.

Arrival At Entebbe:
Image

Between 1971 and 1979 Uganda fell victim to the murderous regime of its then political leader Idi AMIN "Da Da" (it's estimated up to 500,000 people disappeared without trace under AMIN's violent and tyrannical dictatorship). I'm not sure, but, I believe the terminal building evident within these next images is the one (the old airport terminal by the 1970's) where Jewish hostages were held following the Black September hijacking of AIR FRANCE flight 139 on June 27th 1976 (operated by A300B F-BVOG), and prior to the Israeli "Operation Thunderbolt" assault on this terminal, on July 4th 1976, and which resulted their release .... albeit with a few fatalities among the hostages.

The "IDI AMIN" song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFeJJAQPiK4
AMIN's only known reaction to this particular song is reputed to have been .... "DA PEOPLE HOO WOTE AND POBLISHED DAT SONG DAY ALL SHUD BE SHOT FOR DOING DAT" .... or words to similar effect :D

SEVENTH SECTOR (Day 7) - Entebbe/Nairobi

Pre Departure PAX photo at Entebbe:
Image

Departure From Entebbe:
Image

This was the shortest sector of the entire route to Johannesburg .... only some 300 miles or so .... and following a south-easterly VOR track from Entebbe across northern Lake Victoria .... and on into Kenya.

Following departure from Entebbe the enormity of Lake Victoria was evident throughout the first portion of this particular easterly route.
Image
Lake Victoria is not only the worlds largest tropical lake, but also, the largest lake on the African continent too .... with a surface area of some 27,000 square miles and maximum depths ranging from 150 FT to 300 FT. It is also the worlds 2nd largest fresh water lake .... after North America's Lake Superior.

Arrival At Nairobi/Kenya:
Image

SEVENTH SECTOR (Day 7) - Nairob/Livingstoni

Pre Departure PAX photo at Nairobi:
Image

Departure From Nairobi:
Image

This was the longest sector over the entire route .... a distance of just under 1,500 miles .... following a south-south-westerly VOR to VOR track across Tanzania and the southern tip of Zaire .... and on into Zambia. It was also quite a rough/turbulent ride for most of the flight down given the weather scenarios I'd created, but, which is probably "to be expected" whilst overflying this particular tropical geographic region.

Negotiatimg tropical weather build-ups to the north east and during a staged descent prior to arrival at Livingston:
Image

Arrival at Livingston:
Image

EIGHTH SECTOR (Day 8) - Livingstone/Johannesburg

Pre Departure PAX photo at Livingston:
Image

Departure From Livingston:
Image

This final and south-south-easterly sector to Johannesburg was another relatively short route of around 500 miles .... or so .... trending across the borders of both Zimbabwe and Botswana before entering the Republic of South Africa .... to pick up the Johannesburg VOR within 200 miles DME prior to arrival at Jan Smuts International Airport. It was also a great deal smoother/less turbulent than the previous days routing :)

Following departure a quick detour was made to view the Victoria Falls, on the Zambesi River, a very short distance to the south of Livingstone International Airport.
Image
The Victoria Falls straddle the borders of both Zambia and Zimbabwe and are "the largest in the world" .... some 5,500 FT in width and 300 FT in height. The spray from these falls provides 24 hour rainfall to the surrounding lush jungle vegetation and it is one of few places in the world where a "moonbow" (nocturnal rainbow) phenomenon may be observed at night and during certain meteorological conditions ....

Arrival At Johannesburg:
Image

Post Arrival PAX photo at Johannesburg
Image

AVERAGE DH 106 COMET 1 PERFORMANCE EN ROUTE (using modified FDE)


ATITITUDE = 31,000
IAS = 275
MACH = 0.73
GS = 429
TAS = 451 (275 X 1.64 = 451)
ENGINE RPM = 9,550
ENGINE EGT = 453
ENGINE F/F = 1340 LBS per HR (X4 = 5360 LBS per HR )
AI PITCH = + 0.5* (degrees)

This was an appreciably long exercise (some 18 hours total flying time .... and all undertaken in real time too .... although dispersed over several consecutive days), but, one that was (I feel) as educational as it was also enjoyable to fly, so, I encourage anyone (whom wishes to) to consider undertaking exercises such as this .... maybe using Tom's propliners ;)

A couple of things become very clear (to me) over such a long staging virtual route re-enactment like this .... (1) an appreciation of the shear immensity of the African continent .... and (2) although I don't know how BOAC rostered its COMET crews to fly this particular route (whether or not those crews completed a full tour of duty along the entire route and back to the UK, or if some crews might have been based at various destinations/stations along this route), so, assuming the former, it was likely a "very long tour of duty" and during which these crews were obviously away from home for considerable lengths of time.

Mark C
AKL/NZ
Last edited by Mark C on 31 Jan 2018, 05:38, edited 1 time in total.
I know you think you understand what you thought I said but what you thought you heard is not what I meant !

PaulC
VC10
VC10
Posts: 566
Joined: 28 Nov 2009, 15:05
Location: Oakworth, West Yorkshire

Re: BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Post by PaulC »

Morning,
Great report. I love the fact that you went "old school" with the navigation over Africa.
Your opening summary about the three things you look for are very similar to my needs.

Well done and thanks for such a great read!

User avatar
FlyTexas
Red Arrows
Red Arrows
Posts: 7151
Joined: 26 Jun 2004, 10:18
Location: Texas

Re: BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Post by FlyTexas »

Loved your flight report, Mark. Very well done. :thumbsup: The only thing lacking was a British Pathe newsreel announcer. :lol: Thanks for posting your journey in the lovely Comet. :)

Brian

Vancouver
Concorde
Concorde
Posts: 1470
Joined: 05 Apr 2008, 00:27
Location: CYXX

Re: BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Post by Vancouver »

Yes I am inspired to give this one a go when time permits. I love these re-enactments. It would be good if there was somewhere central that could collate and retain all these flights with plans etc...

I am presently trying to re enact the Cannibal Queen flights from the book by Stephen Coonts when he took a Stearman all over the USA. Very good read if you can get hold of it. :thumbsup:
Alex

User avatar
blanston12
Vintage Pair
Vintage Pair
Posts: 2735
Joined: 28 Jun 2004, 20:45
Location: San Francsico, California

Re: BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Post by blanston12 »

Great pictures, I also love these historical recreations.

From what I remember, each of the pyramids were built to for a single Pharaoh and were constructed during their lifetime.
Joe Cusick,

Image
I am serious, and don't call me Shirley.

User avatar
Mark C
Vulcan
Vulcan
Posts: 444
Joined: 23 Nov 2004, 17:29
Location: NZ & Republic of Colombia
Contact:

Re: BOAC COMET 1 London/Johannesburg Route Re-enactment

Post by Mark C »

"THANKS" for the encouraging feedback guys .... much appreciated :)

I do plan a few more of these historic re-enactments .... similar BOAC, AIR FRANCE, and UAT imperial/colonial routes around the same era.

It's just a question of finding the time to be able to start doing so (since once one starts then one doesn't want to be interrupted or otherwise unable to complete the exercise) .... rather than the actual time required to complete it all.

Thanks again ;)

Mark C
AKL/NZ
I know you think you understand what you thought I said but what you thought you heard is not what I meant !

Post Reply